Potential for California
Waste-Based or Other Biomass Ethanol Development
Origin
On March 25, 1999, Governor Gray Davis released Executive
Order D-5-99 directing the California Energy Commission to
evaluate and report to the Governor and the Secretary for
Environmental Protection on the potential for development of
a California waste-based or other biomass ethanol industry.
The Executive Order provides for phase-out of the gasoline
additive MTBE and directs a variety of state agency actions
to establish alternatives to MTBE, including ethanol. This
workplan addresses Task 11 of the Governor's Executive Order
that says:
"The California Energy Commission (CEC) shall evaluate by
December 31, 1999, and report to the Governor and the
Secretary for Environmental Protection the potential for
development of a California waste-based or other biomass
ethanol industry. CEC shall evaluate what steps, if any,
would be appropriate to foster waste-based or other biomass
ethanol development in California should ethanol be found to
be an acceptable substitute for MTBE."
Documents and Notices
Staff Presentation on Background Ethanol Information presented at the Capitol on Wednesday October 3, 2001 to Legislative Staff. It contains material on California's current and future ethanol demand, U.S. ethanol production capability and federal and state ethanol incentives. (Placed on line October 5, 2001, Powerpoint presentation, 116 kilobytes)
"Cost and Benefits of a Biomass-to-Ethanol Production Industry in California", presentation by
Commission staff member Pat Perez, May 8, 2001, Breckenridge, Colorado, at the 23rd Symposium on Biotechnology for Fuels and Chemicals. (Placed on line May 10, 2001, Powerpoint presentation, 785 kilobytes)
DOWNLOAD FINAL REPORT -- Costs and Benefits of a Biomass-to-Ethanol Production Industry in California,
Publication Numbers 500-01-002 and 500-01-002A (Appendices). April 3, 2001, ADOBE ACROBAT PDF file, 197 pages, 1.0 megabytes)
FINAL REPORT -- Report to the Governor: Evaluation of Biomass-to-Ethanol
Fuel Potential in California. Adopted December 22, 1999.
NOTE: Documents below here are preliminary to the final report and are listed here for reference purposes only. Please
refer to final adopted report above.
Annotated Outline of Report: Costs and Benefits of a Biomass-to-Ethanol Production Industry in California. September 19, 2000.
Costs and Benefits of a Biomass-to-Ehanol Production Industry in California, Report dated March 21, 2001 (18 slides, 772 kilobytes)
Los Vegas Costs and Benefits of a Biomass-to-Ethanol Production Industry in California , National Ethanol Conference, February 20, 2001 (16 slides, 1.6 megabytes)
Notice of Committee Hearing, receive comments on the draft consultant report entitled Costs and Benefits of a Biomass-to-Ethanol Production Industry in California.
Workshop to be held February 16, 2001.
Notice of staff workshop to Consider Staff Reports on the Environmental Fate and Transport and Potential Health Effects of Using Ethanol in California Reformulated Gasoline.
Workshop to be held January 18, 2000.
Staff Presentation on Biomass-to-Ethanol
Report given at Commission Business Meeting, December 15, 1999. (Acrobat PDF, 15 pages, 74 kilobytes). Placed on line December 9, 1999. Note: Discussion at the Business Meeting about this item will be broadcast over the Internet.
Notice of a Public Hearing being Held November 19, 1999, on "Evaluation of Biomass-to-Ethanol Fuel Potential in California." Placed on line on October 22, 1999.
Documents for Hearing
Agenda for Workshop
Download Staff Presentation in Microsoft PowerPoint (20 pages, 90 kilobytes)
Download Staff Presentation in Acrobat PDF (20 pages, 77 kilobytes)
Download TRANSCRIPT OF MEETING Acrobat PDF (136 pages, 272 kilobytes)
NOTE: Because this hearing was broadcast LIVE over the Internet, an archive of the actual
hearing is available to listen to in RealAudio. Please go to our
RealAudio Archive page.
COMMITTEE DRAFT Recommended changes and additions to October 1999
Draft Report on Evaluation of Biomass-to-Ethanol fuel potential in
California", December 2, 1999.
(Adobe Acrobat PDF 23 pages, 110 kilobytes).
COMMITTEE DRAFT Report to the Governor on "Evaluation of
Biomass-to-Ethanol Fuel Potential in California", October 22, 1999.
(Adobe Acrobat PDF 133 pages, 500 kilobytes).
COMMITTEE DRAFT Appendices to report: "Evaluation of
Biomass-to-Ethanol Fuel Potential in California", October 22, 1999.
(Adobe Acrobat PDF 267 pages, 1,200 kilobytes).
"Project Update on Biomass-to-Ethanol Fuel Report Activities," presentation by Pat Perez delivered at the U.S. Department of Energy Ethanol Workshop on October 5, 1999.
(Adobe Acrobat PDF, 14 pages, 72 kilobytes)
Transcript of staff workshop held September 10, 1999. (Adobe Acrobat PDF, 183 pages, 364 kilobytes)
"Challenges and Opportunities for Biomass-to-Ethanol Development in California," presentation by Pat Perez, Project Manager, to the
Bioenergy Development and Expansion Conference - Rocklin, California, September 16, 1999. (Adobe Acrobat PDF file, 9 pages, 36 kilobytes)
"Evaluation of Biomass-to-Ethanol Fuel Potential in California"; PowerPoint presentation given at the staff workshop, September 10, 1999. (26 slides, 1.2 megabytes)
Notice of staff workshop on the "Evaluation of Biomass-to-Ethanol" Report, Workshop to be held September 10, 1999.
DRAFT Report to the Governor on "Evaluation of
Biomass-to-Ethanol Fuel Potential in California", August
13, 1999. Executive summary in HTML, full report in PDF.
Ethanol Opportunities in California; PowerPoint presentation given by Pat Perez to
the Governors' Ethanol Coalition, June 22, 1999. (20 pages, 71 kilobytes)
FINAL OUTLINE OF REPORT, June 4, 1999. (10 pages, 24 kilobytes)
For more information, please contact: Pat Perez, 916-654-4527
E-mail: PPerez@energy.state.ca.us
Ethanol Project Team
Pat Perez - Project Manager
Elizabeth Parkhurst - Editor
Primary Authors
Bill Blackburn
Tom MacDonald
Mike McCormack
Val Tiangco
Technical Support
Jeri Fontes
Al Deterville
Gordon Schremp
Gerry Bemis
George Simons
Jairam Gopal
Tom Glaviano
Contract Support
Prime Contractors include: ARCADIS, Geraghty and Miller; SAIC
Commissioner Staff Liaisons
Susan Bakker
Rosella Shapiro
Ken Wilcox
|
Peer Review Group July 16, 1999
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
John Ferrell - United States Department of Energy
Dr. Robin Graham - Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Larry Baxter - SANDIA
Hosein Shapaouri - United States Department of Agriculture
STATE GOVERNMENT
Martha Gildart - California Integrated Waste Management Board
Steven Shaffer - California Department of Food and Agriculture
Dean Simeroth - California Air Resources Board
LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Kay Martin - County of Ventura
ACADEMIC/UNIVERSITY/OTHER
Esteban Chornet - University of Sherbrooke (Canada)
PRIVATE INDUSTRY & ASSOCIATIONS
Kent Hoekman - Chevron
Bob Benson - TEMBEC Chemical Products
Carol Werner - Environment and Energy Study Institute
Bob Dinneen - Renewable Fuels Association
Daryl E. Harms - MASADA
Doug G. MacKenzie - Pacific Rim Ethanol Corporation
David Morris - Institute for Local Self Reliance
|
PROJECT WORKPLAN Updated September 27, 1999
| Activity/Task |
Participants |
Deadline |
| Executive Order D-5-99 |
Governor |
Issued |
| Staff Meeting to Discuss Executive Order |
Eleven Staff |
Completed |
| Meet With Chairman Keese to Discuss Executive Order |
Keese, Shapiro, Brown, Bemis, Gopal, Glaviano, Praul, Deller, Perez and Smith |
Completed |
| Staff Meeting to Discuss Development of Report Outline, Scope of Project, Identification of Stakeholders/Peer Groups and Resource Needs |
Perez, Shapiro, Brown, Bemis, Gopal, McCormack, MacDonald, Blackburn, Simons, Tiangco and Schremp |
Completed |
| Develop Report Outline and Workplan |
Perez, Blackburn, Tiangco, MacDonald and McCormack |
Completed |
| Brief Fuels & Transportation Committee On Workplan and Outline |
Pat Perez |
Completed |
| Develop Stakeholder Lists and Identify Potential Peer Review Group |
Ethanol Project Team |
Completed |
| Develop Work Statement for Technical Contract Support and List Potential Subcontractors |
McCormack and Fontes |
Completed |
| Complete Library Literature Search |
McCormack, Blackburn, MacDonald and Tiangco |
Completed |
| Mail Letter Inviting External Peer Group Review |
Perez |
Completed |
| Finalize Contractor Work Statement and Work Authorizations and Meet With Contractor On Plan |
Perez, Fontes, MacDonald, McCormack, Tiangco and Blackburn |
Completed |
| Prepare Status Report On Ethanol Group Activities to Fuels and Transportation Committee and Management |
Perez |
Completed |
| Data Collection and Analysis |
Ethanol Project Team/Contractors |
Ongoing |
| Prepare Status Report On Ethanol Group Activities to Fuels and Transportation Committee and Management |
Perez |
Completed |
| Progress Report Due From Technical Support Contractor |
Fontes |
Completed |
| Comments Due From Peer Review Group |
Peer Review Group |
Completed |
| Incorporate Peer Review Group Comments |
Ethanol Project Team/Contractors/Primary Authors |
Completed |
| Release Draft Report To Public and Set Date for Fuels and Transportation Committee Workshop |
Ethanol Project Team |
Completed |
| Hold Fuels and Transportation Committee Workshop on Report |
Fuels and Transportation Committee, Ethanol Project Team , Peer Review Group and Contactors |
Completed |
| Summarize Comments Received at Committee Workshop |
Ethanol Project Team |
Completed |
| Prepare Status Report On Ethanol Group Activities to Fuels and Transportation Committee and Management |
Perez |
Completed |
| Revise Report Based On Comments Received From Workshop |
Ethanol Project Team/Contractors/Primary Authors |
Completed |
| Release Draft Final Report With Recommendations and Notice For Public Hearing by Commission |
Ethanol Project Team/Primary Authors |
Completed |
| Hold Commission Hearing on Draft Final Report |
Commissioners and Ethanol Project Team |
November 19, 1999 (TENTATIVE) |
| Incorporate Comments Received at Commission Hearing |
Ethanol Project Team/Contractors |
November 19 - December 1, 1999 |
| Approve Final Report at Commission Business Meeting |
Commissioners |
December 15, 1999 |
| Send Report to Governor and Secretary for Environmental Protection |
Kent Smith |
December 17, 1999 |
Page Updated: April 3, 2001
|