(please change your font to courier for best display) ****************************************************************** California's Electrifying Future the Need for Electric Vehicles by Charles R. Imbrecht Chairman, California Energy Commission November-December 1995 ****************************************************************** Note: This essay was written for Electric & Hybrid Vehicle Technology 95 Magazine for distribution at Second ITS World Conference, Yokohama, Japan, November 1995; and ENV, Detroit, Michigan, USA, January 1996. Written for: Electric & Hybrid Vehicle Technology UK & International Press A Division of AutoIntermediates, Ltd. 120 South Dorking Street Dorking, Surrey RH4 2EU ENGLAND Submitted: July 12, 1995 ****************************************************************** California has been home to many innovations over the years. Technical wizards in the Silicon Valley, and the computers and software they've developed, have revolutionized the way we do business and live our lives. Our movie companies in Hollywood have captivated the world with drama and pathos, comedy and music. Our aerospace companies have built planes that have flown higher and gone faster, and have built components of spacecraft that have gone to the moon and beyond. California's fertile valley soils have been a test bed for crop innovation yielding plants, fruits and vegetables to feed the nation and the world. Our schools have created scores of Nobel-class scientists and scholars. California has even been home to two American Presidents. Once again, California is poised on the edge of innovation. Our state plans to introduce significant numbers of electric vehicles (EVs) into the consumer marketplace in 1998. In that year, two percent of vehicles offered for sale by seven major auto companies will be required to be Zero Emission Vehicles (ZEV). That means that of the 1.3 million vehicles sold in California in 1998, more than 22,000 will be electric vehicles. This increases to 10 percent of all vehicles in 2003. The California Energy Commission has studied alternative fuel vehicles since 1978. Because of its role as the state's primary energy policy and planning agency, the Energy Commission was designated as the lead agency to study alternative fuel vehicles and to help develop the infrastructure needed to fuel those vehicles. In this article, we'll explain the need for electric vehicles, how they will help our environment, a few projects we've undertaken to develop EVs, and a look at how EVs will be integrated into California's transportation sector. Background Californians drive in and ride on more than 23.2 million registered cars, trucks and motorcycles. These vehicles consume more than 13.3 billion gallons of gasoline each year. The numbers will dramatically increase as our population grows from 32 million today to 38 million in the next 15 years. Vehicles emit the vast majority of the harmful pollutants that cause the smog that affects the health of all of us. All of the easy and cheap solutions to clean up our air quality problems have been employed, especially from stationary source emissions. Most of California's factories, businesses and power plants have the best available control technology for pollution. Cleaning up vehicle emissions is both fair and necessary as the transportation sector is called upon to reduce pollution. Electric vehicles are only part of the overall strategy to clean up mobile source emissions. Other strategies include low emission and ultra- low emission vehicles using a variety of fuels such as methanol, ethanol, natural gas and propane; scrapping older more polluting vehicles; encouraging mass transit; and using a cleaner gasoline called reformulated gasoline. This much cleaner form of gasoline goes on sale next year. We expect that gasoline will remain the dominant transportation fuel for many years. But California needs to reduce its dependence on one fuel source to make it less vulnerable to supply disruptions. We have done that in our electricity production. Twenty years ago about two-thirds of all California's electricity came from burning oil. Today, less than one-percent of electricity comes from burning oil. In the process, we have created an industry for renewable energy and advanced power generation that has made California, as some call it, the "energy laboratory of the world." This "portfolio approach" of many sources for electricity production is being extended to our transportation sector, which consumes about one-half of all energy used in California. To neglect this area would doom us to a future of dependency on one energy source when other fuels are available. Therefore, California is looking toward electricity, produced from domestic fuels, for its transportation sector. Energy Although the transportation sector's use of energy is an important aspect of the overall economic well-being of California, the state's ZEV requirement was established to meet health-based air quality standards. Using EVs, however, will have additional benefits beyond just air quality. Energy Commission analyses show that EVs and their associated fuel supply systems will likely be more energy efficient than gasoline vehicles and their fuel supply systems. These fuel supply systems are different, of course, with EVs supplied by electric power plants and transmission systems, while gasoline vehicles are supplied by oil drilling and production, crude oil transportation, petroleum refining, and gasoline distribution. In several studies, which rely upon the state's electricity planning process to predict the likely sources of the state's electricity, California Energy Commission staff has generally found that today's EV would consume less energy on a total fuel cycle basis than does an equivalent gasoline car. System Efficiency Using electric vehicles will make the electricity system more efficient. During off-peak hours when less electricity is consumed, such as over-night, many power plants have to be either shut down or scaled back. The Energy Commission estimates that most electric vehicles will recharge during these off-peak hours when electricity is available and less expensive to produce than during peak periods. California currently has enough excess capacity (the power not used during off-peak hours) to handle the demands of charging millions of electric vehicles. Even by 2010, EVs will only consume 3.2 percent of the total electricity produced. Emissions Studies by Energy Commission staff of electric vehicles' impact on the South Coast Air Basin in Los Angeles find that EVs significantly reduce criteria pollutants, those pollutants for which there are ambient concentration standards. Some pollutants are reduced by more than 90 percent and as much as 98 percent, compared to gasoline-powered vehicles, even when power plant emissions are included. We are confident that carbon monoxide and reactive organic gases (a precursor of ozone) will be greatly reduced. We believe oxides of nitrogen (also a precursor to ozone) will be substantially reduced. Outside of California, emissions may increase as a result of EVs because some of the energy imported to California will come from Southwest United States coal-fired power plants. These results are based on our assessment of electricity produced by Western and California facilities. Western power plants, however, are cleaner than the national average and California power plants are generally much cleaner than the average Western facility. In addition, local air pollution regulatory agencies have significant authority over the amount of pollutants emitted from these Western power plants. The Energy Commission has high confidence that these plants will operate within their emission limits even with any added demand from future electric vehicles. EV Research, Development and Demonstration Electric vehicle technology is not static. Advances are being made by numerous California-based companies such as Hughes Power Control Systems, Amerigon, Allied Signal, Group IX Systems, Kaiser Aluminum, and U. S. Flywheel Systems. To go beyond the initial two percent sales volume, technological advances in batteries, vehicle chassis and auxiliary power options will most likely be required. California's entrepreneurial spirit recognizes a growing marketplace for advanced transportation. In 1992, state and local government joined forces with private businesses to form CALSTART, a consortium devoted to electric and low-pollution vehicles and an advanced transportation industry. More than 135 companies and local government agencies are CALSTART members. The advanced transportation industry is also doing much to help revitalize California's stagnant economy. CALSTART officials say that a third of its members' investments in advanced transportation will be $452 million in 1995, with more than 1,100 new jobs. This will increase to nearly $1.6 billion by 1999 and 13,000 jobs. These are investments in California's future. Our know-how and high-tech expertise in aerospace and computers make California the perfect place to develop an advanced transportation industry. Once developed here, California plans to offer our products and services to the world. Government Support for EVs Government traditionally supports fledgling industry with taxes breaks or other assistance until it can make it on its own. Since 1991, the State of California has invested only $6.3 million into direct electric vehicle research and demonstration programs. These are not tax dollars but are fines paid by oil companies, which over-charged consumers during the oil crises of the 1970s. That small amount of money was matched by more than $47 million from the private sector and others. The federal government is investing much more into R&D on batteries and advanced vehicles. Some of these projects could have dramatic payoffs. We are demonstrating many different technologies, including a project to replace the noisy and polluting diesel buses now operating in Yosemite National Park, with silent and pollution-free electric- powered buses. American Flywheel Systems has received funding for work on an advanced flywheel storage system for EVs. We have also funded development of ultra-capacitors that could assist EVs when large amounts of extra power are quickly needed (such as climbing hills or passing other cars). Only a small amount of state funds is being used for EV incentives (and other alternatively fueled vehicles) to offset the premium price tag on current generation EVs. Those incentives end in 1998 when prices are expected to drop, when there is more competition and as EVs become a mass-consumer product. The California Energy Commission also has initiated a large scale, multi agency consumer demonstration of electric vehicles. Called EV California, the goal is to place 2,000 EVs in fleets and with others by 1997. The Energy Commission, the California Air Resources Board, local air quality management districts, utility companies and others have combined staff and financial resources, technical expertise and support for EV California. How EVs Fit Into California's Transportation Picture The California of the future will be different from today. Better land-use planning that takes advantage of high-tech mass transit and computer-aided highways and vehicles may be part of our future. Commuters may take a small neighborhood electric vehicle to their local mass transit station to then board an electric- powered light- or heavy-rail system to travel to their offices. Such a system is already being planned for San Francisco. The San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) District, along with Pacific Gas and Electric Company, the California Department of Transportation, the Energy Commission and local government, are equipping various BART stations with EV recharging facilities. In a demonstration project, PG&E employees drive electric shuttle vans and smaller (one or two seater) neighborhood EVs (NEVs) to BART train stations. The vehicles will be left there charging for the day. When commuters return at night, the EVs will be ready for them to drive home. Eventually, the idea could expand where, by using a special credit card, anyone could "rent" a small electric vehicle at a station. The credit card would charge the person's account for "rental" of the NEV. They could then return the NEV to that same location or drop it off at another BART station. This concept has worked with bicycles in some cities around the world. Electric vehicles will fit into the general transportation future as would any other new car introduced by the automakers. While their power source is different from an internal combustion engine, EVs are really no different from conventional internal combustion engine vehicles. EVs can handle freeway speeds and all should be safe in crashes. EV drivers who find themselves in one of California's notorious traffic jams create no pollution when compared to their gasoline counterparts. EVs only use power when the accelerator is pushed -- they do not idle like conventional internal combustion engines -- and will not pollute the air as they sit, stuck in traffic. Developing the Infrastructure Much still needs to be done to make California and its cities "EV- ready." Working groups -- made up of utility companies, research institutions, state and local government, and other interested parties -- have formed to discuss a variety of topics. These include: health and safety issues such as amendments to building codes, crash testing of vehicles and response by emergency personnel to vehicle accidents involving EVs; the types of charging connections for vehicles -- conductive or inductive charging; training for mechanics and repair people; and other crucial topics. With the commitment made by these groups, we believe California will be ready for electric vehicles when the mandates become effective in 1998. The number of public charging facilities will grow from about 150 outlets today to tens-of-thousands of outlets at stores, parking lots and even at the curb. Electric vehicles currently do not pay for the electricity they use at these public facilities, though we expect coin- or credit card-operated payment systems to evolve in the future. We are also working to change construction requirements for garages in new homes, parking structures and businesses to make them ready for EV charging. California's love affair with vehicles, spawned out of the expansion of our cities and population growth of the last 40 years, will probably not end. The objects of our affection may, however, be different from today. Rather than high-powered muscle machines, our vehicles may become more utilitarian, with some only for commuting. We may still lovingly rub coat upon waxy coat of polish to our beloved cars, but cars of the future will have different power plants than today. And rather than the "vrooom" of an internal combustion engine, many will probably "purrr" with the soft hum of electric power. # # # Charles R. Imbrecht has been Chairman of the California Energy Commission for more than 10 years and is internationally recognized as an expert on alternative energy and energy policy. A strong advocate of alternative fuel vehicles, Mr. Imbrecht drives a methanol-powered car as his regular vehicle. He has test driven almost all makes. prototypes and demonstration electric vehicles -- from the Solectria Force to solar-powered cars to the GM Impact (in all its phases). His home's garage is already wired for EVs. Fore more information about the California Energy Commission and its programs contact: California Energy Commission Media & Public Communications Office 1516 Ninth Street, MS-29 Sacramento, CA 95814 Phone: 916-654-4989 FAX: 916-654-4420 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * (end of file)