Senate Bill 49 (Skinner, Chapter 697, Statutes of 2019) authorizes the CEC to adopt and periodically update standards for appliances to facilitate the deployment of flexible demand technologies that enable appliance operations to be scheduled, shifted, or curtailed to improve grid reliability and/or to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG) associated with electricity generation (Public Resources Code, Section 25402(e)). This report contains staff’s proposed flexible demand appliance standards for thermostats controlling electric space-conditioning systems. The report contains staff analysis of the cost-effectiveness and feasibility of the proposed standards, as well as discussion of their projected statewide load-shift potential, avoided GHG emissions, related environmental impacts, and benefits.
The proposed additions to Title 20 of the California Code of Regulations set the following proposed standards for HVAC thermostats, a subset of thermostats controlling electric space-conditioning systems:
Automatic scheduling capabilities for heating and cooling loads based on the cost of electricity and grid conditions
Connectivity requirements that enable access to localized grid condition data and keep the on-device clocks accurate
Memory requirements that ensure thermostat access to grid condition data
Minimum consumer preferences and opt-in/opt-out settings that flexible demand schedules must follow
User interface requirements that keep consumers informed and in control of flexible demand capabilities
Open communication standards for participation in demand response programs
Cybersecurity standards to protect consumers using flexible demand appliances
Requirements to make sure updates do not degrade flexible demand capabilities
Marking requirements
Test procedures for devices to demonstrate compliance.
The proposed standards are cost-effective and feasible. The incremental retail cost of compliant HVAC thermostats would increase the cost to the consumer by around $12. This is a one-time expense with no annual ongoing costs. Staff analysis demonstrates that by 2037, assuming complete stock turnover, compliant HVAC thermostats would:
Avoid GHG emissions associated with electricity production by 50,496 metric tons annually,
Avoid 780 MWh of electricity consumption during summer peak period, and
Provide consumers with estimated electricity bill savings of $97 over a 10-year lifetime by allowing the device to automatically shift the time of electricity use.